var UPL_FILES='/Data/UploadedFiles/Forums/';var iUserId='0';var iForumId='1';var iPage='1';var iMessageId=22147;var bRestricted;var bIsRestricted;var bCommunity;var sTopImage;var bCommunityRestricted;var bIsAdmin=false;var sPagingName='Forum.aspx?Id=1';var sMenuOptions="";var userEditMessageViews = 10;var userDeleteMessageViews = 1;var sForumName="פורום הדף היומי";var AdminArr=[new Admin("1","מנהל האתר","1"),new Admin("49","מנהל הפורום","1"),new Admin("86","ברוך","2"),new Admin("125","דוד כוכב","2"),new Admin("159","עציוני","2"),new Admin("199","המכריע","2"),new Admin("249","כדי","2"),new Admin("919","יום יום ידרשון","2")];var TagArr=[new Tag("דף יומי - יתרונות מול חסרונות","http://www.daf-yomi.com/forums/message.aspx?id=729")];var MgrMsgArr=[new MgrMsg("שימו לב! בכתיבת הודעה בפורום יש לשייך את ההודעה למסכת ודף","http://www.daf-yomi.com/forums/message.aspx?id=350"),new MgrMsg("המלצה","http://www.daf-yomi.com/forums/message.aspx?id=4168"),new MgrMsg("מקלדת וירטואלית לטובת הכותבים מחו\"ל","http://www.daf-yomi.com/forums/message.aspx?id=455")];var MostViewedArr=[new MostViewed("107076","אמר רב חסדא מידת חסידות שנו כאן","לינקוש","22/04/24 15:26","58","47"),new MostViewed("107079","מה זה מפרכסין ?","מרדכי דב זינגר","25/04/24 18:44","807","30"),new MostViewed("107080","קשר בין איסור ריבית לבין יציאת מצרים","לינקוש","28/04/24 08:18","58","6")];var ClosedMsgsArr=[new ClosedMsgs("65830"),new ClosedMsgs("65874"),new ClosedMsgs("65795"),new ClosedMsgs("21834"),new ClosedMsgs("65886"),new ClosedMsgs("66030"),new ClosedMsgs("66259"),new ClosedMsgs("66250")];var MessageArr=[new Message("22147","0","שאלת חכם","27/08/12 18:34","ט אלול","תשע"ב","18:34","עם הארץ","מעשה בתלמיד שבא לפני רבי יהושע

האם אפשר לשאול חכם אחר לאחר ששאלו חכם אחד וקבלו תשובה?
כמו ברפואה יש second opinion","248","","4262","True","True","False","","1225","74.233.66.97","0","0","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22148","22147","חצי תשובה","27/08/12 18:51","ט אלול","תשע"ב","18:51","דוד כוכב","אפשר, אם לא שאל כהוראה למעשה.","125","","4262","True","True","False","","145","212.76.113.73","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22149","22147","אם הודיע","27/08/12 18:56","ט אלול","תשע"ב","18:56","כדי","לחכם השני שכבר שאל, הרי זה מותר וכמ"ש התוס' ע"ז (ז.). וכאן מבואר שהודיע לר"ג ששאל את ר' יהושע.","249","","4262","True","True","False","","195","79.183.210.25","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22214","22148","'חצי' תשובה?","28/08/12 17:24","י אלול","תשע"ב","17:24","זקן ומסכן","","320","","4261","False","True","False","","83","95.86.82.157","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22152","22149","ראה ברמ"א על שו"ע יו"ד רמב, לא.","27/08/12 23:03","ט אלול","תשע"ב","23:03","אלעד סטופל","","282","","4262","False","True","False","","108","212.76.110.83","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22194","22149","ואם הודיע לאחר ששאל כפי שקרה אצלנו?","28/08/12 12:39","י אלול","תשע"ב","12:39","אלעד סטופל","","282","","4261","False","True","False","","140","212.76.110.83","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22201","22194","לענ"ד אין חילוק לפי הטעם","28/08/12 13:31","י אלול","תשע"ב","13:31","כדי","שמתבאר מהתוס' ומהשו"ע שציינת.","249","","4261","True","True","False","","172","79.181.221.115","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב",""),new Message("22255","22214","כן","29/08/12 04:10","יא אלול","תשע"ב","04:10","דוד כוכב","על דרך הלשון שכתבו הספרים: "שאלת חכם חצי תשובה".

חצי התשובה השני - בחלקו הביאו פה המשיבים האחרים. ועוד, שפרטי ההלכות בזה תלויים בשני הטעמים שכתבו הראשונים לדין שאין חכם השני רשאי להורות בדבר שהחכם הראשון הורה בו, אם הוא מצד כבוד החכם הראשון, או מצד שהשואל קיבל עליו כנדר.","125","","4260","True","True","False","","117","212.76.113.73","0","22147","ברכות|כז ע"ב","")];var iTotalPages=810;var SeverTime;fInitTree();getPersist(82534);